Hiring a Property Management Company Guide

Deciding to bring in a property management company is a pivotal moment for any landlord. It’s the point where you shift from being a hands-on manager, fielding tenant calls and fixing leaks, to becoming a strategic investor focused on the bigger picture.

This change usually happens when you realize the day-to-day grind of managing properties is costing you more than just money—it’s costing you time, energy, and the opportunity to grow. It’s not about losing control; it’s about gaining your freedom back.

Knowing When to Hire a Property Manager

The urge to manage your own properties is strong, especially when you're just starting out. The logic seems simple: why pay someone else a percentage of your rent when you can just do it yourself? I get it. But this thinking often misses the very real, and often expensive, hidden costs of going it alone.

We're not just talking about dollars and cents here. Think about the mental drain from late-night emergency calls, the stress of chasing down late rent, or the sheer anxiety of trying to decipher complex landlord-tenant laws. Every hour you spend trying to find a reliable plumber is an hour you aren't spending scouting your next deal.

The True Cost of Self-Management

Most new landlords only focus on one number: the management fee. What they don't factor in are the financial leaks that spring from inexperience and not having the right resources at your fingertips.

Let’s look at a few all-too-common scenarios:

• Long Vacancies Bleed You Dry: A good property manager has a finely tuned marketing machine and often a list of pre-screened tenants ready to go. They can fill a vacancy in a couple of weeks, not a couple of months. Just one extra month of vacancy can easily wipe out an entire year's worth of management fees.

• One Legal Mistake Can Be Devastating: Are you 100% certain you know the exact, step-by-step legal process for an eviction in your state? One small procedural error can get your case thrown out of court, forcing you to start the clock all over again while a non-paying tenant sits in your property.

• Paying Retail for Repairs: Professionals have a roster of vetted, insured, and reliable contractors. Because they provide consistent work, they get preferred pricing and priority service. When you’re self-managing, you’re on your own, often calling around frantically and paying top dollar for last-minute help.

To put it in perspective, let's compare the two approaches directly.

Self-Management vs Professional Management a Quick Comparison

Task	Self-Management Reality	Professional Management Advantage
Tenant Screening	Relying on gut feelings and basic credit checks. High risk of placing a problem tenant.	Multi-point background checks (credit, criminal, eviction history) reduce placement risks significantly.
Rent Collection	Chasing down late payments, awkward conversations, inconsistent cash flow.	Automated, professional systems for on-time payments and streamlined, legally compliant late-fee enforcement.
Maintenance	Scrambling to find contractors for every issue, often overpaying for emergency service.	Access to a network of vetted, cost-effective vendors who provide priority service.
Legal Compliance	Trying to keep up with constantly changing federal, state, and local housing laws.	Expertise in landlord-tenant law, Fair Housing, and local regulations protects you from costly lawsuits.
Your Time	Your property is essentially a part-time (or full-time) job, taking you away from family and growth.	Your property becomes a truly passive investment, freeing you to focus on strategy and acquisitions.

Ultimately, choosing professional management isn't just about offloading tasks; it's a strategic decision to professionalize your investment and protect your bottom line.

The real question isn't whether you can manage your property, but whether you should. Your time has a value, and for most serious investors, it's far better spent on high-level activities like finding new deals and building the portfolio.

Shifting from Expense to Investment

Seeing that management fee as an investment, not an expense, is a crucial mindset shift. It's a strategic move to protect your asset, streamline operations, and pave the way for future growth. The industry is expanding for a reason—the U.S. property management market is projected to hit USD 7.66 billion by 2033.

Hiring a pro turns your property from a demanding second job into a genuine investment. This is what allows you to scale your portfolio with confidence, knowing the daily fires are being handled by experienced experts.

If you're still on the fence, our detailed guide can help you run the numbers and decide if property management is worth it for your specific situation.

Alright, you've decided a property manager is the right call. Smart move. Now comes the real work: finding the right one.

A quick Google search will give you a list of names, but the best managers rarely come from a cold search. The real gems are usually found through people who are already in the trenches.

Think about who you already trust in the real estate world. Your agent, your lender, even your real estate attorney—these folks see the good, the bad, and the ugly of local property management. Give them a call. They can give you the unvarnished truth about who’s reliable and, just as importantly, who you should steer clear of.

Tap Your Network for Real-World Intel

Another goldmine of information is your local Real Estate Investor Association (REIA). If you’re not a member, it’s worth dropping into a meeting. You’ll be in a room full of other landlords who are more than willing to share who they use and what their experience has been. This is where you get the inside scoop on who really performs.

Beyond your immediate circle, look at professional organizations. The National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM) is the gold standard. A manager who has a NARPM designation has gone the extra mile, investing in their education and committing to a code of ethics. It's a solid indicator of professionalism.

Start Vetting Your Shortlist

Once you have a handful of promising names, it's time to do some homework. Your first stop should be their website. Does it look like it was built this decade, or is it a relic from 2005? A company's website is its digital storefront—if it’s sloppy and outdated, it’s a red flag about how they run the rest of their business.

Next, hit the review sites. Check out what people are saying on Google, Yelp, and the Better Business Bureau, but read between the lines. A single bad review isn't a dealbreaker, but a pattern of complaints about poor communication or slow maintenance definitely is. Pay close attention to how they respond to negative feedback. A professional, problem-solving reply is a great sign. This entire process is about choosing the right service provider by seeing how they handle themselves in public.

Remember, you're not just hiring someone to collect rent. You're handing over a massive asset and trusting them to be your partner. The goal here is to weed out the non-starters before you waste time on interviews.

The U.S. property management industry is a whopping $134.2 billion market, with residential properties making up the lion's share. That means you have plenty of options. Your job is to filter through the noise to find the perfect fit for you and your investment. This initial screening is the foundation for a long and profitable partnership.

The Essential Vetting and Interview Process

You’ve got your shortlist of promising candidates. Now the real work begins. This is where you have to look past the slick websites and five-star reviews to figure out how these companies actually operate day-to-day. A great sales pitch is one thing; competence in the trenches is another entirely.

Your main goal here is to understand their processes, not just listen to their promises.

Think of it this way: you’re only spending time on the phone with companies that have already passed your initial gut check.

Asking Questions That Reveal Real Competence

Generic questions will only get you generic, rehearsed answers. Don't ask, "Do you screen tenants?" That’s a simple "yes" or "no."

Instead, ask, "Can you walk me through your exact tenant screening process, from the moment an application lands on your desk to the lease signing?" The difference is huge. A truly professional manager will be able to detail a systematic, multi-step approach without even blinking.

You're listening for specifics, like:

• Credit Score Minimums: Do they have a hard-and-fast minimum score, or is it flexible? Why?

• Income Verification: How, exactly, do they confirm income? Are they collecting pay stubs and bank statements? A rock-solid standard is requiring a gross monthly income of at least 3x the monthly rent.

• Background Checks: Are they running comprehensive criminal and eviction history reports on every adult applicant?

• Reference Checks: Do they actually call past landlords? What specific questions do they ask to get beyond the usual "they were great" response?

While you're at it, ask about their marketing. Inquire about their specific property listing optimization strategies. A company that knows how to market a property effectively is one that will keep your vacancy rates low.

Key Takeaway: The best property managers operate on well-defined, documented systems. If their answers are vague or they seem too willing to bend the rules just to get a unit filled, consider it a major red flag. Their first job is to protect your asset, not just to fill a vacancy.

Probing Their Emergency and Eviction Protocols

How a company handles a crisis is the ultimate test of its metal. A pipe will burst at 2 a.m. on a holiday weekend—it’s just a matter of when. You need to know their plan.

Ask for a real-world story. "Tell me about the last after-hours emergency you handled for a client." Who gets the call? Do they have a trusted list of vendors who will actually show up? And critically, what's their spending limit before they need your authorization for a repair? Clear, confident answers tell you they’ve been there and done that.

Evictions are another area where you simply cannot afford inexperience.

Don't just ask if they handle evictions. Ask them to describe their step-by-step process. A competent manager will speak with authority, referencing local and state laws, the specific legal notices they serve, and the typical timelines. If they sound hesitant or unsure, it’s a glaring sign they lack the experience to navigate this legally treacherous process, putting you and your investment at serious risk.

To really dig in, check out this list of 8 essential property manager interview questions for 2025 to help you get to the core of how they operate.

The Power of the Case Study

Finally, it's time to move from hypotheticals to reality. Ask them for a specific case study that showcases their problem-solving skills in action.

Frame the question like this: "Tell me about a time you dealt with a difficult tenant who was always paying late and causing problems with the neighbors. What steps did you take, and what was the final outcome?"

This one question can be more revealing than a dozen others. You’ll get a real sense of their communication style, their approach to conflict resolution, and their practical understanding of landlord-tenant law. A great manager will have a story at the ready—one that demonstrates professionalism, a strict adherence to legal procedure, and ultimately, a positive resolution for the property owner. This is the final piece of the puzzle in hiring a property management company you can truly trust.

Decoding Management Agreements and Fee Structures

The property management agreement is where the rubber meets the road. It’s the legal backbone of your entire partnership, but let's be honest—it’s usually dense, packed with legal jargon, and can feel downright intimidating.

But rushing through it or just skimming for the price is one of the biggest—and potentially most expensive—mistakes an owner can make. This isn't just paperwork; it’s the official rulebook for how your investment will be managed, protected, and monetized. Let's break down what really matters so you can sign on the dotted line with complete confidence.

First, Understand the Fee Models

At the heart of any agreement, you'll find the fee structure. Most property management companies stick to one of two primary models. The "cheapest" option on paper often isn't the best for your actual return, so it pays to know the difference.

• Percentage-Based Fee: This is the industry standard. The company charges a percentage of the monthly rent collected, typically somewhere between 8% and 12%. The key phrase here is "rent collected." Never, ever agree to pay a management fee for a vacant unit. This simple detail ensures their interests are aligned with yours—they only make money when you do.

• Flat-Fee Model: Other companies charge a set dollar amount every month, no matter what the rent is. This can look very attractive, especially for properties in high-rent areas where a percentage fee feels excessive. Just make sure the quality of service doesn't dip because their income isn't tied to performance.

Getting a handle on these basic models is just the start. To really compare apples to apples, you need to dig deeper into all the other potential charges. For a much more detailed breakdown, check out our complete guide to property management fee structures.

Uncovering the Hidden Costs

The monthly management fee is just the headline. The real story is often in the fine print, where additional fees can quickly turn a great deal into a costly one. You have to scrutinize the contract for these common add-ons.

Pro Tip: Before you even get the contract, ask for a complete, itemized fee schedule. A transparent company will hand it over without hesitation. If they get cagey or say "it's all in the agreement," that’s a massive red flag.

The table below outlines some of the most common fees you'll encounter.

Common Property Management Fee Structures and Hidden Costs

Fee Type	Industry Standard Range	What to Watch Out For
Leasing Fee	50% to 100% of first month's rent	Does this fee apply if a tenant breaks the lease early? Is it charged again for a renewal?
Lease Renewal Fee	$100 - $300 flat fee, or a small %	Some top-tier companies don't charge this, arguing that retaining good tenants is part of the job.
Maintenance Markup	5% - 15% on vendor invoices	Is this markup capped? Do they get multiple bids for jobs over a certain amount (e.g., $500)?
Eviction Fee	$200 - $600 plus court costs	This fee should only cover their administrative time, not the actual legal bills from an attorney.
Account Setup Fee	$0 - $300	This is a one-time charge. Many reputable firms have eliminated this fee entirely.
Vacancy Fee	A flat monthly fee (e.g., $50)	A fee charged while the unit is empty. This is a red flag, as it misaligns incentives.

Remember to ask direct questions about every single line item. A good property manager will be happy to explain their value and justify their costs.

Key Clauses You Absolutely Cannot Ignore

Beyond the money, a few other clauses in the agreement dictate the entire dynamic of your relationship. These sections define your rights, their responsibilities, and your exit strategy if things go south.

Pay special attention to the Termination Clause. What happens if you're unhappy? A fair contract should allow you to terminate with 30 to 60 days' notice. Some might include an early termination penalty, but be extremely wary of any agreement that locks you into a long-term contract with no reasonable way out. You need an escape hatch.

Also, look for Service Guarantees. This is where a company puts its money where its mouth is. Do they offer a tenant guarantee, promising to find a new tenant for free if the one they placed is evicted within a certain timeframe? What about a satisfaction guarantee? These clauses show a company is confident in its processes and is willing to stand behind its work—a critical sign you're hiring a true partner, not just a vendor.

Spotting the Red Flags: What to Run From

You can have the most beautiful property on the block, but the wrong management company will turn your investment into a nightmare. Knowing what a good property manager looks like is only half the job. The real skill is learning to spot the bad ones before you sign on the dotted line. A slick sales pitch can hide a multitude of sins, so you need to know the warning signs.

The first, and maybe biggest, red flag is simply a lack of communication. If it takes them days to return your initial call or their emails are vague and unhelpful, that's not just bad customer service—it's a preview of how they'll treat your tenants. A well-run company is a responsive one. Period.

It's also incredibly tempting to go with the cheapest option. Don't. Choosing a manager because their fee is a percentage point lower than everyone else's is a classic rookie mistake. Those rock-bottom rates are almost always balanced out by tacked-on fees, marked-up maintenance costs, and subpar service that ends up costing you a fortune in vacancies and repairs.

Shady Practices and Outdated Tech

You need to drill down into their tenant screening process. Seriously. With rental application fraud becoming more sophisticated, a manager who just "runs a credit check" is leaving you wide open to professional tenants and costly evictions.

The 2025 Property Management Benchmark Report from Buildium really highlights this problem. It found that a staggering 70% of property managers have seen a spike in fraud attempts, but only 16% are actually confident they can catch it. This is why the best firms are using AI-powered tools to verify identities and financials. If a potential manager can't walk you through their specific, multi-step screening protocol, they're already behind the curve.

Other Warning Signs to Watch For

Beyond the obvious, a few other things should make you think twice.

• A Pattern of Bad Reviews: One disgruntled ex-tenant is understandable. But if you see a consistent theme across multiple reviews—complaints about unreturned security deposits, ignored repairs, or sloppy accounting—that’s not a fluke, it's a business model.

• No Boots on the Ground: A national company with a slick website might seem impressive, but if they don't have a real, local office and staff, they can't handle the realities of management. Who’s going to show the property? Who’s handling the 3 AM emergency call?

• No Professional Connections: Reputable managers are typically members of professional organizations like NARPM (National Association of Residential Property Managers). It shows they’re committed to their craft and adhere to a code of ethics. A lone wolf might just be a lone wolf for a reason.

Remember, the interview isn't just for them to win your business. It's for you to audit their entire operation. If your gut tells you something is off, listen to it. Dodging a bad manager is just as important as finding a great one.

Your Final Checklist for Hiring a Property Manager

You’ve done the research, sat through the interviews, and picked apart the contracts. You're almost there. This is the moment to take a deep breath and run through one last, crucial check before you sign on the dotted line.

Think of it as the final pre-flight inspection. Skipping these last steps is where tiny oversights can snowball into major headaches later on. Let’s make sure this partnership is truly ready for takeoff.

Final Verification and Reference Checks

Before you commit, it's time to verify everything the company has claimed. More importantly, you need to talk to the people who know them best: their clients.

Don't settle for a curated list of their happiest customers. Any company can produce a few glowing reviews. Instead, get specific with your request.

• Ask to speak with a current owner whose property is similar to yours in size, type, and location. This gives you the most accurate preview of the service you can expect.

• Here’s the real test: ask for the contact information of an owner who left their service within the last year. Their reasons for leaving are pure gold. Was it a simple case of selling the property, or was there a service issue?

A truly confident property manager won't flinch at this request. This part of hiring a property management company is your best chance to get an unfiltered look at how they perform when things aren't perfect.

Confirming Licensing and Insurance

This is non-negotiable. A legitimate property management company operates with the proper credentials, and it's your job to confirm they have them. This is all about protecting yourself and your investment.

First, check their state real estate broker’s license. Most states require property managers to be licensed brokers, and you can typically verify this in seconds on your state's real estate commission website. An unlicensed manager is a red flag you can't afford to ignore.

Next, you need to see their proof of insurance. Ask for a copy of their insurance certificate. Look for two specific types of coverage:

• General Liability Insurance

• Errors & Omissions (E&O) Insurance

That E&O policy is especially critical. It protects you from financial fallout if they make a mistake or are negligent in their duties.

Don’t just take their word for it—get the documents in hand. A legitimate business will have its Certificate of Insurance ready to go and won't hesitate to send it over. This simple piece of paper is your assurance that they're a professional operation.

Clarifying the Onboarding Process

Okay, one last thing. You need to know exactly what happens the minute you sign the contract. A messy, confusing start is often a sign of a disorganized company.

Ask them to walk you through their onboarding plan. How will they get started? What’s the timeline?

Get clear answers to questions like:

• What documents do you need from me right away?

• How will you inform my current tenants about the change in management?

• When do you schedule the initial property inspection?

A professional team will have a well-defined, documented process. Their answers should give you a sense of confidence and clarity, setting the stage for a transparent and successful partnership from day one.

Final Questions Before You Sign the Dotted Line

Even after you've done your homework, checked references, and narrowed it down to a top contender, a few nagging questions usually remain. Getting straight answers to these final concerns is what separates a good choice from a great one. Let’s walk through the questions I hear most often from property owners.

So, What's This Actually Going to Cost Me?

This is always the first question, and for good reason. While fees can vary, the industry standard for a monthly management fee is between 8% and 12% of the rent collected. That last part is critical—never sign an agreement where the fee is based on scheduled or potential rent. If you don't get paid, they shouldn't either.

But that monthly percentage is just the starting point. To understand the full picture, you need to dig into the other fees that will inevitably pop up.

• Tenant Placement Fee: This is a big one. Expect to pay anywhere from 50% to 100% of the first month's rent for the work involved in finding and placing a new, qualified tenant.

• Lease Renewal Fee: Some companies charge a smaller, flat fee for renewing a lease with a great tenant who's already in place. It’s a fair charge for the administrative work involved.

• Maintenance Markups: It’s common for firms to add a small percentage on top of invoices from vendors. This covers their time for coordinating repairs, vetting contractors, and ensuring the work is done right.

Before you commit, always, always ask for a complete, itemized fee schedule. Surprises here are never a good thing.

How Do You Handle Evictions?

Let's be honest, no one wants to deal with an eviction. A seasoned property manager won't just "handle it"—they'll have a rock-solid, legally compliant system in place. This isn't something they improvise.

Their process should be clear: serve the correct legal notices on time, and if the tenant fails to comply, file the appropriate paperwork with the courts to get the legal eviction process started. A good manager acts as the buffer, handling all the difficult communication and working directly with legal counsel. You should be completely insulated from the stress.

My Two Cents: A manager's skill in navigating an eviction is one of the most valuable things you're paying for. Any hesitation or inexperience on their part can lead to months of delays and thousands in lost rent. This is where pros earn their keep.

What if I'm Not Happy? Can I Cancel the Contract?

You should always have an out. Your management agreement will specify the terms, but yes, you can terminate the contract. Most agreements run for a one-year term but will contain a termination clause that spells out exactly how to part ways.

Typically, you'll need to provide 30 to 60 days' written notice. Read this section carefully, as some contracts include an early termination fee. Knowing your exit strategy before you enter the agreement is just smart business. It ensures you’re never trapped in a partnership that isn't working.

How Do I Know What's Happening With My Property's Finances?

Any modern, professional company will give you 24/7 access through an online owner portal. Think of it as your real-time dashboard for your investment.

From this portal, you should be able to pull monthly financial statements, see copies of maintenance invoices, and review inspection reports whenever you want. Get clarity on how often they update the portal and what level of detail you can expect. The right company wants you to be informed.

---

At Keshman Property Management, we've built our business on total transparency. As landlords with over 20 years in the trenches ourselves, we know what owners need: clear communication and reliable systems that make owning property profitable and hands-off. To see how our straightforward approach works, learn more at mypropertymanaged.com.